The Menu · Crown Heights, Brooklyn

Drink well. Stay a while.

Cocktails built with intention. Cold drafts. Rum worth asking about. Bites made for another round.

Signature Cocktails

The house pours, island first.

Fresh juice, house infusions, and rum from the islands. Ask for it spicy, ask for it strong, ask for it frozen.

The Rum Punch at The C List Cocktail Bar

House favorite

The Rum Punch $12

Island rum, pineapple, orange, lime, a dash of bitters. The one you came for.

The Love Potion at The C List Cocktail Bar

House favorite

Love Potion $14

Blackberry, hibiscus, white rum, lime, crushed ice.

Frozen

Frozen Margarita $13

Blanco tequila, lime, agave, salt rim. Add mango or passion fruit, $1.

Hibiscus Mule at The C List Cocktail Bar

House favorite

Hibiscus Mule $13

Vodka, hibiscus, ginger beer, lime.

Sorrel SpritzSorrel, prosecco, soda, orange peel. Christmas in a glass, all year.

$13

Passion Fruit DaiquiriWhite rum, passion fruit, lime, simple. Shaken hard.

$13

Jerk PalomaTequila, grapefruit, lime, jerk-spiced rim.

$14

Coconut Espresso MartiniVodka, coconut rum, espresso, coffee liqueur.

$14

Mango Chili MargaritaReposado, mango, lime, chili salt.

$14

FroséRosé, strawberry, lemon. Frozen. Dangerous.

$12

Ting and StingGin, Ting grapefruit soda, lime, a little heat.

$12

Planter's PunchDark rum, pineapple, orange, grenadine, nutmeg.

$13

The Classics

Done right, no shortcuts.

Stirred when they should be stirred. Shaken when they should be shaken. Never rushed.

A classic coupe cocktail at The C List Cocktail Bar

Old FashionedBourbon, demerara, bitters, orange, cherry.

$14

NegroniGin, Campari, sweet vermouth. Perfectly balanced, ask anyone.

$14

Espresso MartiniVodka, espresso, coffee liqueur. Better than the $25 one.

$14

MargaritaBlanco, lime, triple sec. Rocks or up, salt or no salt.

$13

MojitoWhite rum, mint, lime, soda. Add passion fruit, $1.

$13

Whiskey SourBourbon, lemon, egg white, bitters.

$13

Dark and StormyDark rum, ginger beer, lime.

$12

Aperol SpritzAperol, prosecco, soda, orange.

$12

ManhattanRye, sweet vermouth, bitters, cherry.

$14

PalomaTequila, grapefruit soda, lime, salt.

$12

Beer · Wine · Rum

Something simple, poured well.

Rotating taps, an honest wine list, and a rum shelf built around where the owner grew up.

On Draft

Red Stripe

Brooklyn Lager

Guinness

Rotating IPAAsk what's on.

Modelo Especial

Rotating SourFruit-forward. Ask.

Wine

Sauvignon Blanc

$12

Pinot Grigio

$11

Rosé

$12

Prosecco

$12

Pinot Noir

$13

Cabernet Sauvignon

$13

The Rum Shelf · St. Lucia. Jamaica. Barbados. And a few friends.

Appleton Estate 8Jamaica

$12

Chairman's ReserveSt. Lucia

$12

Mount Gay Black BarrelBarbados

$13

Wray and NephewJamaica. Overproof. Respect it.

$10

Diplomático ReservaVenezuela

$14

Plantation PineappleBarbados

$12

The Island FlightThree half-pours from the shelf, chosen by the bar. Ask about tasting nights.

$24

Food

Made to share, or not.

Small plates built for a bar. Enough to keep the night going, not enough to slow it down.

Jerk fries at The C List Cocktail Bar, Crown Heights

Jerk fries. Order two.

Jerk FriesHand-cut, jerk seasoning, scallion, house aioli.

Jerk Chicken WingsSix wings, jerk glaze, lime, pickled onion.

$14

Beef PattiesTwo Jamaican patties, flaky, spiced.

Plantain Chips and DipCrispy plantain, avocado-lime crema.

Coconut ShrimpFive shrimp, coconut crust, mango dip.

$14

Oxtail SlidersTwo sliders, braised oxtail, slaw, brioche.

$16

Loaded PlantainsSweet plantain, black beans, cheese, scallion.

$11

Curry Chicken BitesGolden curry, roti strips for dipping.

$13

Taco TuesdayChef Spice Catering takes the kitchen every Tuesday from 6pm. Rotating tacos, cash-friendly.

from $4 each

Every single day.

Happy hour is a daily practice here.

Four to seven, Monday through Saturday. Sunday it runs five to ten because Sundays deserve it. No reservations, no catch.

Get Directions

Happy Hour Menu

House cocktails$9
The Rum Punch$8
Draft beer$5
House wine$8
Well drinks$7
Jerk fries$6

Mon to Sat 4 to 7pm · Sunday 5 to 10pm